Alligator Army: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





College Sports and Character

Urban Meyer was in Miami Wednesday when he made comments addressing the latest incident that involved Jamar Hornsby and a stolen credit card. Rather an acknowledge mistakes made by the program (failing to properly discipline Hornsby for two prior incidents) he placed part of the blame on the NCAA.

 

''The NCAA is pulling us off the recruiting process,'' he said, in comments reported by South Florida media outlets. "I'm not allowed to go out [to visit players] anymore. I'm not allowed to text message. I'm trying to find out as best I can. You just keep re-evaluating.

"If you just look around and see some of the things that are going on, it's amazing. It's concerning. It's alarming," Meyer said. "So we take a great deal of time and effort in trying to educate guys, work with them and recruit character. Are we perfect? Absolutely not."

I cannot speak for Florida Football because I don’t know the depth of punishment Hornsby received for being charged with criminal mischief and for selling his Georgia tickets. Any college student or athlete could do that and still be a fine citizen. But it takes a special level of narcissism and disrespect to do what Hornsby did. And that is where Florida and every institution has failed.

One of the things that has always bothered me about college sports was the appearance that some of the players (sorry, student-athletes) are merely screws in a giant money making machine. This idea has filtered down to now looking at high school kids and judging them on 40 times and bench reps. What’s the difference then between men on Wall Street salivating over the next big IPO and men on Gator Country boards salivating over the next big QB? After all, if the IPO or QB fails, there will be another one to fill the spot in a few months.

I’m not saying Hornsby was another screw in the machine, but the lack of effort put into punishing him reflects back on UF. Was there a lack of effort because they did not care? Or because they needed him so desperately on special teams? I tend to think it is the first option. Think of it this way; if your son causes $750 in damage and then breaks a rule, how hard do you punish him the second time? Is it hard enough that he learns a lesson? I would think so.

Pointing the finger at Meyer or even the Gators coaches is not my point here because this is a national thing that has been going on for years. Christian Peter at Nebraska, Jerramy Stevens at Washington; examples of young adults allowed to do what as they please. Universities have to take a much larger role in the lives of their athletes. Don’t just give them physicals, send them to a psychiatrist, and not to, “Awaken the Giant within,” or some motivational BS. (Most schools have the cash to do this. But they spend it on leather chairs in skyboxes.) Colleges have to learn more about these kids beyond 40 times and bench reps. Maybe something could be spotted before one athlete thinks it is acceptable to steal a dead student’s credit card. Meyer wants to address character, well, getting back texting privileges won’t lead to any deeper understanding of the mind of an 18-year old.

I don’t know what leads to teams keeping on players who break rules. Maybe they are afraid what happened to Florida women’s basketball will happen to them. In 2005, Florida standout Bernice Mosby thought the appropriate way to deal with a teammate was to attack her. She was kicked out of school, went to Baylor and was an All-American candidate who was drafted in the WNBA. She could have helped Florida, but made a personal decision and UF responded.

Meyer and all college coaches need to understand that if you’re not going to put in the effort to understand these kids, don’t put in the effort to keep them around.

0 recs | Comment 3 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

I agree with most of what you’re saying, but sometimes you just can’t know what’s coming. I mean, how many times have you heard on the news “Oh, he was a nice guy, very friendly every time I talked to him” about some criminal who did something really bad? Or the kid who gets in trouble at school who was the quiet kid that just kept to himself?

I have no idea what kind of teammate Hornsby was, or how he acted around coaches and at practice. There was a hint that money could be a tripping point for him, since he sold those tickets, but how could someone have taken that piece of information and expected he’d steal and use a deceased girl’s credit card? If a person is capable of doing that, he is certainly capable of lying to a psychiatrist to better hide his flaws.

I understand Urban Meyer’s point about getting less personal interaction with recruits. The sort of people who are going to know the most important red flags about a recruit – his coaches, teammates, family and friends – are not likely to report them because they want that recruit to get that offer from the big schools. I’m sure many recruits put on a good act during the recruiting process, but the more interaction time there is, the harder it is to stay in character.

In the end, people from the ages of 18-22 are going to make bad decisions and exercise bad judgment on occasion. Sometimes Brandon James will be in the wrong place at the wrong time with Brandon Powell. Sometimes Dorian Monroe will decide cutting the boot off his car makes more sense than waiting for the towing company. Sometimes guys will get in fights over whatever because they erroneously decide that violence is the answer.

I’m not sure what more Meyer could have done with Hornsby. He suspended him for 5 games last fall, which is one of the largest penalties I’ve seen him give out next to kicking a guy off the team or suspending Ronnie Wilson for a year.

by Year2 on May 15, 2008 4:39 PM EDT   0 recs

That’s the thing, we know guys make dumb decisions. My problem is that it is only addressed after they do something dumb.

mlmintampa
UF C/O 06

by mlmintampa on May 15, 2008 6:25 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Maybe Meyer could have kicked Hornsby off the team instead of a 5 game suspension? It was his 2nd offense and he was still a freshman. One thing is for sure….if Meyer continues to give slaps on the wrist, why would his players not take chances on doing stupid things?

It’s okay, if I get caught, coach will give me another chance.

Unless Meyer takes a hard stance and starts pulling scholarships and kicking players off the team for multiple offenses, we are on a one-way train to being Thugville, USA.

by skigator93 on May 22, 2008 3:23 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Florida Gators.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
The Blind Side and the Bell Curve
Galagaship_small
Welcome to the new Alligator Army and SB Nation
Small
Wuerffel to host Jacksonville luncheon on May 15, 2008
Small
Exciting New Football Team in Florida
Rockmnation_small
TDs: The Runs Batted In of College Football Statistics (Part Two)
Rockmnation_small
TDs: The Runs Batted In of College Football Statistics (Part One)
Small
He15man History
Small
Tebow Called Out!
Small
Why the Noles will win today
Small
We could have be #1 in the BCS ranking

Post New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter