In 2004, Tennessee won with a last second field goal after a 15-yard unsportsmanlike penalty by Dallas Baker gave them good field position. While the SEC eventually admitted mistakes in assessing penalties (they should have been offsetting as Baker's punch was a response for getting punched) and running the clock (the clocked stopped after the penalty, giving UT extra time they should not have had), Baker was fingered as the goat.

When Florida returned in 2006, Baker had four catches for 54 yards, two touchdowns, including this game winner from Chris Leak.